Engine oil loyalties are an odd thing, like gasoline brand loyalties and cigarette brand loyalties. Belief in what is 'best' seem to go right down to our DNA.(How many times as a wide eyed wonderous kid I heard some adult male relative proclaim with great certainty and confidence, that he never puts anything but Shell gasoline, or Chevron gasoline or whatever in his car, the inference being that the brand in question is obviously and unarguably the best gasoline available)
We humans are odd critters.
I've casually followed the 'which engine oil for wet clutch equipped ATV' subject for several years now. The concept that Shell Rotella T6 is an oil of choice for a wet clutch equipped ATV seems to have been an idea that grew wings all on its own. Someone posted that it is compliant with JASO MA2 rating and that it can be bought relatively cheaply by the 5 gallon bucket at auto parts outlets, and someone else confirmed the report, and another, and a star was born.
I'm not an advanced study in engine oil science but any time I've been tempted by a display of T6 oil I have read the print that T6 is intended for diesel engines, and my innate caution has steered me away. Oil is not where I economize and save a couple of bucks.
Is T6 a wonderful super oil? Not impossible I suppose but a person would only know for sure if they had an identical control ATV undergoing an identical amount of use in identical conditions but using a different oil, for instance the recommended Lucas oil.
Then do compression tests and leakdown etc.
Without a control comparison we don't really know, rather we believe.
Me, I'm just going to keep using the recommended oil of the recommended grade, and CF Moto filters, and if per chance something goes thud, warranty wise my nose is clean.
I hope.