To update on this, i ended up replacing my front bumper. Was a little tricky to get the top/ side plastics off and removing the push rivets from the wheel wells, but all things considered, the install went pretty well.
The only difference was that the holes for the winch fairlead on the old bumper were M8 and the same holes on the new bumper are M10. I wonder why they made that change... No real difference to me other than that I needed to find some M10-1.25x20 stainless bolts which aren't the most common locally.